Construction disputes often begin with everyday management failures: unclear instructions, undocumented variations or delayed decisions. For Employers and Contractors in Malta, an appropriately selected FIDIC contract can provide a framework for addressing these issues while keeping works progressing.
Research supports this practical value. Chen and colleagues’ 2018 study, Understanding the Multiple Functions of Construction Contracts, published in Construction Management and Economics, identifies Control (Safeguarding and Governance), Coordination and Adaptation as significant functions within FIDIC contracts. This supports viewing the contract as a tool for organising performance and responding to change throughout construction. [1]
Barczak and Richter’s 2021 research on construction projects in Poland identifies: (i) more effective project management, (ii) easier dispute resolution, and (iii) reduced risk, among FIDIC’s advantages. However, it also identifies more investment in administration due to increased staffing and financial demands. [2]
Resolving disagreements during the works
Under the 2017 Red and Yellow Books, the Engineer is to seek agreement on relevant matters and claims and, where agreement fails, makes a fair determination. Disputes may then proceed through the contractual procedure to a Dispute Avoidance/Adjudication Board (DAAB).
Its decisions are binding and require compliance, even where a timely challenge preserves recourse to arbitration following the prescribed settlement stage. This enables issues to be addressed during construction rather than accumulated until completion. [3]
Broader empirical evidence supports dispute boards’ usefulness. King’s College London’s 2024 international survey found that most respondents experienced subsequent proceedings following board decisions only infrequently. That evidence concerns dispute boards generally, rather than FIDIC alone. [4]
Making the framework work
For a project in Malta, legal advice should address the appropriate form and edition, risk allocation, choice of law, and mandatory legislation. Thus it is imperative that Particular Conditions are carefully drafted with full knowledge on the FIDIC contracts and their Golden Principles, and the governing law and arbitration arrangements.
Parties must organise trained teams, clear decision-making authority, communication lines, updated programmes, contemporaneous records and reliable systems for contractual notices and deadlines.
They should appoint and fund the DAAB promptly to avoid unnecessary delays and ensure smooth project implementation.
FIDIC merits consideration because it connects project management with structured dispute resolution. Its effectiveness depends on parties understanding and actively using the procedures they adopt, both having the completion of the Project as their primary goal of this contractual relationship.
References
- Chen, Y., Wang, W., Zhang, S. and You, J. (2018). Understanding the multiple functions of construction contracts: the anatomy of FIDIC model contracts. Construction Management and Economics, 36(8), 472–485. View study.
- Barczak, B. and Richter, M. (2021). Impact of the FIDIC Contract Conditions on the Implementation of the Construction Projects in Poland. Communications of International Proceedings, 2021(53), Article 3823221. View study.
- Gillion, F., Morson, R., Jackson, S. and de Jager, C. (2018). The New FIDIC Suite 2017: Significant Developments and Key Changes. International Construction Law Review, 35, 384–407. Read via FIDIC.
- Nazzini, R. and Macedo Moreira, R. (2024). 2024 Dispute Boards International Survey. King’s College London, Centre of Construction Law and Dispute Resolution. Findings published 9 December 2024. View survey.

